Worksite Wellness: Are We Having The Impact We Desire?
Making an impact requires us to have clarity of purpose
Posted on 03-21-2018, Read Time: Min
Share:
The beginning of a New Year is an ideal time to take stock of the impact of your worksite wellness program is having on both the organization and its participating employees. Assessing your impact is critical for three key reasons:
- You certainly want to be making a difference
- You can better manage what you measure
- Leading experts in worksite wellness are questioning program impact
In recent years, Drs. Michael O’Donnell (PhD) and Ron Goetzel (PhD) have raised significant issues regarding program impact. Here is what they said or wrote:
- In 2013, Dr. O’Donnell, then Editor-In-Chief of the American Journal of Health Promotion, wrote in a journal editorial: “My guess is that most programs, maybe 90% - 95%, lack the necessary program components and are too superficial to have much impact.” (1)
- In 2016, Dr. Goetzel is quoted as saying: ““There is a group of about 100 employers whose programs have really smart ingredients” and follow best practices, Goetzel said. “But thousands of other [employers] still don’t do wellness right” and “are not getting good health outcomes.” (2)
In addition to the concerns of these two worksite wellness leaders and researchers, recent research studies and program evaluation studies have also cast doubt on the impact of worksite wellness programs. As recent as January 2018, the researchers of a random control designed worksite wellness program at the University of Illinois Urbana – Champaign reported in their findings that they found no evidence of impact in their first year’s results.
They wrote this, even though they are still evaluating their first year results around employee biometrics. They must, therefore, be pretty confident in their results. (3)
If we are not having an impact, then what should we, as worksite wellness practitioners, do? Continuing to do more of the same does not seem to make much sense here. Continuing to do more of the same sounds, to me, like Einstein’s definition of insanity. A definition we have all read or heard before.
Be an Impact Maker
Making an impact requires us to have clarity of purpose. There needs to be clarity around our why. Why are we creating the worksite wellness program? Why are we offering a worksite wellness program to employees? The why may be singular, or the why may involve multiple purposes. In either case, our why must be clearly articulated across the whole organization. Everyone should know and be able to state why the worksite wellness program exists.
Within our purpose, we need to be authentic. We need to be able to clearly articulate what the worksite wellness program will accomplish and not accomplish. And more importantly, we need to be in a position to be able to prove it when and if asked.
Making an impact requires alignment. There needs to be alignment between the worksite wellness program and the rest of the organization. This includes the organization’s purpose, mission, vision, values, beliefs and plans. In other words, there needs to be integration. Everyone needs to know how all the pieces fit together in a common purpose.
There also needs to be alignment between the worksite wellness program and employee needs, wants and desires. Employees need to see how what they are being offered will enhance their life or solve an immediate pain point or problem.
In terms of alignment, there also needs to be alignment between the program’s purpose and the programming and interventions delivered through the program. What is offered needs to address your stated purpose. Otherwise, how will you achieve your purpose?
Finally, in order to know you are having an impact, you need to monitor, measure and evaluate. Otherwise, how do you know you are making any progress towards achieving your purpose? The metrics you use need to reflect the program’s purpose. Monitoring, measuring and evaluation do not have to be hard or difficult. Between different quantitative and qualitative types of evaluation methods, there are many the worksite wellness practitioner can employ without the help of an outside researcher or program evaluator.
As a worksite wellness practitioner, you should ask and answer these three questions for yourself:
Within our purpose, we need to be authentic. We need to be able to clearly articulate what the worksite wellness program will accomplish and not accomplish. And more importantly, we need to be in a position to be able to prove it when and if asked.
Making an impact requires alignment. There needs to be alignment between the worksite wellness program and the rest of the organization. This includes the organization’s purpose, mission, vision, values, beliefs and plans. In other words, there needs to be integration. Everyone needs to know how all the pieces fit together in a common purpose.
There also needs to be alignment between the worksite wellness program and employee needs, wants and desires. Employees need to see how what they are being offered will enhance their life or solve an immediate pain point or problem.
In terms of alignment, there also needs to be alignment between the program’s purpose and the programming and interventions delivered through the program. What is offered needs to address your stated purpose. Otherwise, how will you achieve your purpose?
Finally, in order to know you are having an impact, you need to monitor, measure and evaluate. Otherwise, how do you know you are making any progress towards achieving your purpose? The metrics you use need to reflect the program’s purpose. Monitoring, measuring and evaluation do not have to be hard or difficult. Between different quantitative and qualitative types of evaluation methods, there are many the worksite wellness practitioner can employ without the help of an outside researcher or program evaluator.
As a worksite wellness practitioner, you should ask and answer these three questions for yourself:
- What is my worksite wellness program about, really?
- What are we doing here?
- How will the future of this organization and the employees who work here be different because of us?
Beat the impact odds. Have clarity of purpose, be authentic, align everything you do and monitor, measure and evaluate. As worksite wellness practitioners, we can and should be making a difference. And, be able to prove or demonstrate that we are.
References
- O’Donnell, Michael. 2013. Does Workplace Health Promotion Work or Not? Are You Sure You Really Want To Know The Truth? American Journal of Health Promotion. Volume 28, Number 1, September – October, pp.iv – vi.
- Begley, Sharon. 2016. Do Workplace Wellness Programs Improve Employees’ Health? February 19, 2016. Available electronically at:
- Jones, Damon. Molitor, David. Reif, Julian. 2018. What Do Workplace Wellness Programs Do? Evidence from the Illinois Workplace Wellness Study. Available electronically at: http://www.nber.org/workplacewellness/results/ Accessed: January 31, 2018.
Author Bio
As a worksite well-being professional, William McPeck has training and experience in both in worksite wellness and the emerging field of worksite well-being. His professional training includes program development, program implementation, consulting, training and coaching in wellness, mental health and substance abuse. Bill specializes in helping employers and wellness program coordinators launch wellness programs and to enhance existing programs. Bill is also a Certified Worksite Wellness Program Consultant, Certified Wellness Culture Coach, Certified Work-Life Professional and Certified Holistic Stress Management Trainer.
Connect William McPeck |
Error: No such template "/CustomCode/topleader/category"!